[quote="abendx"]You know.... I've thought about buying a couple of el chepo handhelds for just this reason. Talking AM sucks balls and IMO the handhelds are MUCH better than AM in every way, even at 5w. Out at JV I carry my VX-8DR around camp with a zero gain antenna (you know, one those 2" jobbies) and can pick up about 80% of what I can from the rig with a real antenna.[/quote]
The last time we were all in JV (goatfest), Richard and I couldn't hear you after we got about a mile away. But I could hear Richard and the rest of the URF guys from camp on the lakebed, and they were on the Fissure Mt trail - about 10 miles away.
Dusty has a nice handheld tri-band, and had to use his peaked and tuned CB on freeway ridge because me and rob couldn't hear him more than a couple miles out - but he was loud and clear on a tuned CB pushing 15 watts. He now has a diamond mag mount antenna and connects to 12v power and gets pretty damn good range. Adding a real antenna really made that HT perform much better.
Travis also has a handy talkie, and he can't reach the race car when its at the other end of the short-course track at the stampede (about 5 miles).
My handheld that I use to monitor races (Yaesu FT60) Hits the repeater traffic great in JV (race ops), but I couldn't talk to crew members on simplex when they would head into a trail. At home, I can contact people on simplex about 10 miles out when in farmland. I can hit a repeater from my work that is about 25 miles away if atmospheric conditions are great. Not too bad for an HT with a rubber ducky.
What I have found in the last couple years playing around with these things on the trail: with flat terrain, good line-0-sight, and favorable atmospheric conditions - a 5 watt handheld is good. When wheeling in hilly terrain, canyons, bad weather - the extra power output of a dedicated mobile station really makes a HUGE difference on simplex. The 75 watts of the 2900r is a BEAST on the trail.
Having said that, I would take a 5 watt HT over most of the poorly turned/installed CBs in the club in a heartbeat

Half of the CBs in this club are unusable
